Why is it so hard to remember dialogues in a dream? Speaking for myself, I remember all the visual imagery and the feelings that came with it, and I remember having talked to this or that person, and may have remembered the subject of the conversation. But what exactly was said remains a mystery. This applies to everything related to ´words´: writing words, reading words, recited poems, and so forth.
I think it is a pity since dialogues in dreams can be one of the more interesting aspects to analyze. Take this for an example. Tonight* I did remember a dialogue.
To understand any of it you have to know some of the history in reality leading to this.
Kosta is a man I fell crazy in love with more than two years ago. We had some great conversations and flirting episodes going on when at some point this turned into a two year long lasting ignorance and tension from both sides. I call it cold war. I did numerous attempts to reconnect with him but he refused and kept ignoring me. I moved to another place and since then (about two to three months now) I have not seen him. So now for some reason I dream about him trying to reconnect with me.
In this particular dream, I walked towards my bicycle and noticed a diary laying on my saddle. It turned out to be his and I thought he may have put it there on purpose. I was flipping through the pages and may have paused at a drawing of a naked woman when Kosta came up to me:
Kosta: ¨I used to see women over 18 and fuck them. They´re getting younger now.¨ (laugh)
silence
Me: ¨Why do you come up with this now?¨
Kosta: (chuckle) ¨It seems we can act normal now.¨
Me: ¨We could have always acted normal. If you would have just said something to me or asked something I would have acted normal.¨
...
Me: ¨You couldn´t have planned this. I am already living in Enschede.¨
Kosta: ¨Oh Enschede? When I lived in Enschede, I always went to this pub. There were always ....¨
I woke up.
And now the version explaining the logic of this dialogue and all the subtleties in it:
Kosta: ¨I used to see women over 18 and fuck them. They´re getting younger now.¨ (laugh)
silence
Kosta in reality does not seem to care about cheating on his girlfriend. This interpretation of him would be an exaggerated Kostaversion which is no surprise since dreamcharacters are often exaggerated.
After this sentence it remained silent for a while and I looked at him. This sentence put me very much back into reality, the reality of a man that was obviously not the right one for me and from whom I´d better stay away.
It was silent for a moment, I looked at him and I first wondered why did I fall in love with such a man; he was obviously so wrong to me, and then I felt the attraction again.
Me: ¨Why do you come up with this now?¨
I was referring to him showing me his diary and talking to me. I assumed this was his way of explaining the course of things to me. For two years he ignored me so why was he doing this?
Kosta: (chuckle) ¨It seems we can act normal now.¨
I thought: ¨He probably does not feel threatened anymore because I left and will never come back so it is easier for him to ´act normal´ now.¨
Me: ¨We could have always acted normal. If you would have just said something to me or asked something I would have acted normal.¨
True. Very very true. An attempt to reconcile again.
Me: ¨You couldn´t have planned this. I am already living in Enschede.¨
I went to visit the place where he and I used to work, but obviously it was two months now since I had gone, so he would not know when I would be there. I assumed he was not carrying his diary with him all the time and he only had it with him especially for the purpose of showing me. It felt like he wanted to show me some of his former life to explain his actions.
Kosta: ¨Oh Enschede? When I lived in Enschede, I always went to this pub. There were always ....¨
Kosta seemed surprised either that I lived in Enschede or that I also lived in Enschede like he once did. In reality he has never lived in Enschede, he has lived in Italy, Greece, England and two places in the Netherlands. The last part I forgot but it had to do with some bottles or artwork or whatever that was present at the pub Kosta was talking about. At that point I woke up.
What strikes me so much about this dialogue, apart from the fact that it is Kosta talking to me, which will always strike me, is the way it differs from reality and at the same time the reality of the dialogue itself.
What makes this dialogue so different from reality is that there seems to be spoken only the words that matter, the heart of what is most important. I more or less immediately ask him about his motives, tell him what is the deal, that we could have always acted normal. Through the conversation I more and more realized that he really was not in love with me, it would have never turned into a relationship and that it was OK. When the most important was said, and Kosta moved on to a normal chat about his former life in Enschede, I woke up. In reality, words are decorated with more words, words to soften or introduce other words. What mattered was said so there was no reason to stay in the conversation and I could wake up.
Another difference from waking life was the fact that I assumed certain things to be the case, like his motives of showing me the diary, his reason to be surprised about me living in Enschede and such. This in itself is not different from reality. What was different is that we conversed based on these assumptions as if they were true and the other person knew about them. In reality one can never be sure about these things and you will have to ask the other person to be sure. In dreams, that what you assume turns out to be true so there is no need to ask or to be uncertain.
The reality of the dialogue lies in the fact that there are so many subtleties in the words spoken: the intonation, the considerations leading to them being said, the reaction to the words of the other. I wanted to say one thing, but I said another. I felt the same antagonistic feelings combined and interchanging after one another of attraction and reality, attraction and the hurt of it. I noticed a feeling of reconciliation and acceptance. He spoke words the same way he would in reality with the same kind of smile, the same kind of expression on his face. The content of the sentences were extremely Kosta-like. His composure when he walked to me and started to talk. The same relaxation I felt when still talking to him in reality. Etcetera.
The most surprising of all is that I was the one making this all up. My own brain created this dialogue when at the same time it felt as if it was him creating his words and me creating mine. I wouldn´t have come up with his first note about fucking younger women and apparently I was the one who did. It is strange.
Summary so far:
1. A dream dialogue as opposed to a real life dialogue can get to the point, without ´decorative words´ to introduce the difficult words or soothen them unnecessarily.
2. In dream dialogues the people talking assume certain things and these assumptions nearly always turn out to be true. Because of this, there is no need to question your assumptions and you can easily talk about that what matters.
3. People talking to you in a dream can show exactly the same characteristics as in reality as well as say things the same way they would in reality. Feelings and thoughts show the same subtlety and changeability as in waking life.
4. This is surprising because you are the only one creating these dialogues. Yet they do come as a surprise and do not seem created by yourself, unless maybe you are lucid.
Now the question remains
how to remember dialogues. The mechanisms are the same in reality. I can give you the following hints:
1. Pay attention to what is said. Without attention, there will be no memory. Stronger put, a dream dialogue will lose its sense and turn into brabble or the scene will shift to another scene when there is no attention.
2. Become lucid. This will make you remember the dream better. It can however disrupt the conversation and make it less interesting.
3. When you are lucid and able, keep repeating that what was said, revisit the dialogue.
4. Wake yourself up when you have enough information in store and more will probably be forgotten or when you shift to another scene and will therefor forget what was said. You can wake yourself up by withdrawing from your dream. Go to sleep and you will wake up.
5. When you wake up lay still and repeat the dialogue inside your head, again and again while trying to keep hold of the feelings associated with it.
6. Remember the context in which it was placed. Contextual thinking leads you back to the details.
7. Think associatively. If you can still remember ´diary´ then search for associations of that word that may had to do with it. Dreams are led by association so there probably took place an association that led to the next spoken sentence.
8. Think backwards. If you only remember the last words spoken, try to remember what was the last words spoken before that. If you can´t remember, try to imagine what could have been said.
9. When you can´t think of anymore turn into another position to see if that helps you remember something. When you are still in recall mode, do not turn on the light, move or start thinking about the grocery list or whatever you were planning to do today.
These methods obviously are applicable for every part of the dream you want to remember. They will work for about any aspect of dreams, such as imagery, feelings, sounds and smell.
I have not found a specific method yet for remembering dialogues as opposed to other elements. Sorry about that.
*I wrote this about a month ago, so a month ago would be ´tonight´.
Do you remember dialogues as easily as other dream elements? Do you have specific methods to remember them better?